Contractor Quote Comparison Tool
Project Details
Enter your project information to get an accurate comparison
Add Contractor Quotes
Enter details for multiple contractors to compare side by side
Compare Your Quotes
Click the Calculate button to analyze your quotes and identify potential red flags
Quote Comparison Results
| Contractor | Labor Cost | Materials Cost | Contingency | Total Cost | Payment Terms | Red Flags |
|---|
Recommendations
Key Takeaways
- Start with trusted sources - neighbours, trade bodies and reputable review sites.
- Verify the contractor’s licence and insurance before any paperwork.
- Ask for a detailed portfolio and at least three recent references.
- Get written quotes, compare them line‑by‑line, and watch for hidden fees.
- Never pay the full amount up front; use staged payments tied to completed milestones.
When you need a kitchen remodel, a roof fix, or a new extension, the biggest risk isn’t the construction itself - it’s hiring the wrong person to do it. Reputable contractor is a building professional who holds valid licences, carries adequate insurance, has a proven track record, and maintains transparent business practices. In this guide you’ll learn a step‑by‑step process to locate such a professional in your neighbourhood, avoid common scams, and seal the deal with confidence.
1. Map Out Where to Look
Most homeowners start their search online, but the best leads often come from offline networks. Combine the two for a balanced pool.
- Neighbourhood referrals: Ask friends, family, or the local residents’ association. People who’ve had a job done recently will tell you which contractors kept to budget and schedule.
- Trade associations: organisations like the Federation of Master Builders maintain member directories that only include businesses meeting strict standards.
- Online review platforms: websites such as Checkatrade or Rated People aggregate customer scores, photos of completed work, and complaint histories.
- Local council resources: Many councils publish lists of contractors who have successfully completed recent building‑permit inspections.
Write down the names that appear in at least two of these sources - that overlap is your first quality filter.
2. Confirm Licences and Insurance
A License verification check is non‑negotiable. In England, most building work requires a CPCS (Construction Plant Competence Scheme) or an NVQ‑level qualification. Ask the contractor for their licence number and cross‑reference it on the CSCS database.
Next, request a copy of their Insurance certificate. The policy should cover public liability (minimum £5 million) and workers’ compensation. A quick phone call to the insurer can confirm the policy is active and matches the contractor’s name.
Skipping either step can leave you liable for accidents or unpaid bills if the contractor disappears.
3. Scrutinise the Portfolio and References
A solid Portfolio showcases recent projects similar to yours - think “extension”, “kitchen fit‑out”, or “roof replacement”. Look for before‑and‑after photos, timeframes, and materials used. High‑quality portfolios often include client testimonials and brief case studies.
Ask for at least three Reference checks. Call the provided contacts, verify the work conducted, and ask about:
- Schedule adherence
- Budget accuracy
- Communication style
- After‑care or warranty claims
If any reference sounds vague or hesitates to answer, treat it as a red flag.
4. Get Detailed, Written Quotes
Quotes should break down labor, materials, equipment hire, and any subcontractor fees. Use the table below to compare two or three contractors side‑by‑side.
| Criteria | Contractor A | Contractor B | Contractor C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Labour (hrs) | 120 | 110 | 130 |
| Materials cost | £8,500 | £9,200 | £8,300 |
| Contingency (10 %) | £950 | £1,020 | £830 |
| Total (incl. VAT) | £12,970 | £13,440 | £12,460 |
| Payment terms | 30 % deposit, rest on milestones | 50 % upfront, 50 % on completion | 40 % deposit, final on completion |
Pay attention to the payment schedule. A reputable contractor will link each instalment to a measurable milestone (e.g., demolition complete, cabinets installed).
5. Conduct the Interview - What to Ask
Meeting the contractor face‑to‑face lets you gauge professionalism. Use this checklist:
- How long have you operated in this area?
- Can you provide a copy of your public liability insurance?
- Do you subcontract any work? If so, how do you vet them?
- What is your typical project timeline for a job of this size?
- How do you handle unforeseen issues or change orders?
Take notes and compare responses later. Consistency across your shortlist signals reliability.
6. Spot the Red Flags
Even with a polished portfolio, some warning signs betray a risky hire:
- Reluctance to provide licence numbers or insurance details.
- Quotes that are dramatically lower than the market average - usually a sign of cut‑corners or hidden costs.
- Absence of a written contract or vague terms about warranties.
- Negative reviews on multiple platforms that mention the same issue (e.g., missed deadlines).
- No affiliation with a recognised Trade association or local builder’s guild.
7. Seal the Deal - Contract Essentials
Once you’ve chosen the best fit, lock everything in a written contract. Include:
- Scope of work - detailed description of every task.
- Materials - brands, grades, and warranty periods.
- Timeline - start date, key milestones, and final completion date.
- Payment schedule - linked to milestones, with clear terms for late payments.
- Insurance & indemnity clauses - stating the contractor’s responsibility for damages.
- Dispute resolution - preferably mediation before legal action.
Both parties should sign two copies; keep one for your records.
Quick Vetting Checklist
- Ask neighbours or colleagues for recommendations.
- Check licence number on the CPCS/CSCS database.
- Request current insurance certificate (≥ £5 m public liability).
- Review a portfolio of at least three similar projects.
- Contact three references and note their feedback.
- Obtain written, itemised quotes from at least two contractors.
- Interview using the question list above.
- Look for red flags - low‑ball pricing, missing paperwork, poor online reputation.
- Sign a detailed contract with milestone‑based payments.
How can I verify a contractor’s licence quickly?
Ask for the licence number, then visit the official CSCS or CPCS website. Enter the number and confirm the name, expiry date, and qualification level. A quick phone call to the issuing body adds extra assurance.
What insurance coverage should I expect?
At a minimum, the contractor must hold public liability insurance of £5 million and workers’ compensation. This protects you if a worker is injured on site or if property is damaged during the project.
Is it okay to pay the full amount up front?
Never. Pay a small deposit (usually 10‑30 %) to secure the schedule, then release further payments only after each milestone is completed and inspected.
What should I do if the work to date is unsatisfactory?
Document the issues with photos, reference the contract clause on quality standards, and raise a formal written complaint. If the contractor does not remedy the problem within the agreed timeframe, you can invoke the dispute‑resolution process outlined in the contract.
Are online review sites trustworthy?
They’re useful, but treat them as one data point. Look for patterns - multiple reviews mentioning the same strength or weakness are more reliable than a single five‑star comment.